兔子先生传媒文化作品

Skip to main content

Good books stoke youthful visions, perspectives

Original article can be found at听听听
Originally published on December 9,听2017听By Tim Rowland听

It cannot be argued that it is normal to pretend to be starving on the American prairie. Yet as a child, this is precisely what I did, and perhaps in that I am not alone. Blame those serial troublemakers, the authors of good books.听

It would听usually happen on pancake night, the pancakes representing coarsely milled flour and the bacon representing precious scraps of salt pork. More drama probably plays out on a little boy鈥檚 dinner plate than in a whole season at the Kennedy Center, and I would gravely apportion the foodstuffs, piling up little cairns of pancake and separating out the fatty part of the bacon from the lean.听

The rest of the performance involved nibbling, very slowly, first the pancake and then the hoarded pork product. My companion was Laura Ingalls Wilder, and the scene was a desolate sod cabin parked directly in the path of a howling blizzard. How I made it out alive I don鈥檛 know.听

By the time 鈥淟ittle House on the Prairie鈥 became a TV series, I was over it. That and, no offense to Michael Landon, but any attempt to live up to the expectations created by my own imagination was bound to fall short.听

Today, young and adventurous readers have Harry Potter, but a half century ago there was Laura Ingalls, a child who did not rub elbows with wizards, yet was every bit as heroic to a sizable swath of mostly rural (I鈥檓 guessing) young people whose fantasies 鈥 probably for the last time 鈥 were heavily influenced by the American Wild West.听

Reviewing a new biography of Wilder 鈥 鈥淧rairie Fires: The American Dreams of Laura Ingalls Wilder鈥 by Caroline Fraser 鈥 Patricia Nelson Limerick, writing for The New York Times, says, 鈥淲ilder won for herself the status of a pre-eminent figure in the shaping of the myth of the West 鈥 that seductive collection of icons, images and articles of faith installed in millions of minds and souls worldwide.鈥澨

As with the television show, I don鈥檛 know whether to buy into this book, because there are so many ideals that are there for the shattering. As a boy, for example, I looked upon Pa as a rock. A determined man of superhuman conviction who with a firm hand guided the family ever further west in the face of impossible adversity.听

It never dawned on me that he was more like a fiddle-playing ne鈥檈r do well, who participated in the great migration west not out of any听particular heroism, but because he had no other choice.听

Whether these pioneers were brave and bold as we have been taught somewhat misses the point. Many pioneers were forced west because they had failed to make a go of farming not once or twice, but multiple times. They moved west not out of valor, but because the creditors had caught up to them and they were losing their land. Had Pa been any good at farming, chances are he would have stayed put.听

The point is that they persevered, and if they failed, it wasn鈥檛 for a lack of trying.听

The 鈥渨hys鈥 of the westward expansion never occurred to young readers, at least they didn鈥檛 to me. Children measure success with different yardsticks, and we didn鈥檛 care about the number of figures in a person鈥檚 bank account, we found value in adventures accumulated, in hardships overcome, in life lived.听

If Pa had been working every day from his study, overseeing a successful agricultural concern, we would have no use for him. We didn鈥檛 want to know about his retirement account, we wanted to be there with him at a party shucking听corn, or听stomping our feet to his lively fiddle. We loved Pa, and Pa loved his family, we could see, and wasn鈥檛 that enough?听

It is only later, as adults, that we shake our heads over Pa鈥檚 checkered existence, and听wondered听why he was such a failure, why the family always had to move on.听

Pa, for one, might beg to differ. Yes, we knew about his pain, the gaunt cheeks from a lack of food; the hands numb with cold; the tiny stores of grain (or pancakes as the case may be) that warded off starvations; the Christmases when the most spectacular gift was a simple orange.听

But we allowed ourselves to accept that pain and setbacks are part of the deal. We didn鈥檛 demand that every break in life go our way. We understood that a little girl could be a hero, every bit as capable as the men in her world.听

Good for us, and good for books like 鈥淧rairie Fires鈥 that make us think about this stuff. For it鈥檚 quite the revelation that when we read Wilder鈥檚 books so many years ago, we were in some ways far wiser than we are now.听